Wow, Singapore Straits Times gave us 11 pages of effective journalism, effectively highlighting the Singapore church environment as some kind of a freak show full of pretense and frivolous glam.
I understand where they come from la really, mixing business and religion: marketing (a concept based on nothing substantial) and money (trouble-maker) comes into the mix. These things eventually will affect what’s being preached, how the service is being run and eventually, attracting certain kinds of people. Certain indulgences churches invest in, does raise eyebrows and just like how the cover go, ‘critics worry that Jesus may be lost in the razzmatazz.”
The objective of the article is lost in the report. I mean if you actually read it all, it elaborates nothing less than a huge freak show, where they make the readers really wonder how these tens of thousands can be so blind by all the lights and sounds.
But do the lights and sounds really blind them: Is their rock concert style really something we should harp on considering charismatic churches have been jumping like that for decades? Are the prosperity sermons really cunning baits as people say they are, when there are promises in the bible aligned to that? I see no conscious effort to firstly introduce the clueless why Christians tithe, worship or even elaborate on why Christians go to church. Tens of thousands willing to come. I don’t think they are that gullible and stupid as the papers portray them to be la.
Unfortunately, like a face palm/poke your own backside, there are some of those quotes by loose tongued preachers and Christians who really should just shuddap.
Don’t get me wrong, i am very open to criticism against christianity being a believer of doubt, but I can sniff out people who if it were a general paper exam, they will fail very badly. Remember mega churches are one end of the trajectory of church behavior, throwing in an insight into the small churches thing at the penultimate page was done as if to sympathize with the ‘other’ side of the picture is all but a halfhearted attempt. Its really the same side of the picture when you portray the way churches ‘steal’ members from each other. Everyone chooses his or her comfortable church pls. No one is stealing anyone from anyone; there is no competition at all. Churches want new converts than one who already is a christian it’s called evangelism. ‘Church shopping’ as they put it is really, finding the right church you are comfortable with this has been going on for decades and people move church for reasons ranging from marriage to shift house. We are really spoilt for choice! Yes, 700 churches here, but that doesn’t mean that we compete.
However I agree with Matthew Matthew’s point on page 4 abt the appeal of this modern structure of church building for megachurches. Their delving into business as part of their growth strategy is a grey area. Singaporeans are kiasu, money loving, and hardworking success chasers. That’s why success-chasing christians here would choose churches that ‘gravitate towards the big, efficient and successful’. mega churches are ‘trendy, cool, and market savvy’, a blessing to be part of that organization where everything is so famous, big, grand and comfortable. So I guess some clever entrepreneurial pastors had seized the opportunity to make use of the local culture and trends here to good use. If you look at it in a way whereby them investing in such amounts to put on such a show, allow them to attract so many new converts at such a fast rate, is it really a bad investment of their money? Even to me, a hard-core critical person, I say no, good effective investments keep it up.
We need to get it into our heads that religious establishments can be rich; many have been rich, for centuries all over the world. But if somehow there is valid proof of abuse of money, the church is corrupt and I’m sure the church would dissolve by itself. If churches indulge in prosperity messages over and over, more than any other messages, it’s not giving the congregation the full picture. If churches investment in activities which purpose is far from divine where you cant trail back it’s link to say evangelism or discipleship, these are those I feel are also worthy to be lamented on the papers. There were hints of this happening but not enough evidence or follow up on it at all, leaving me perturbed and making wild guesses.
This brings me to my next point. What amazes me are also some of their choice of photographs in the article, namingly a few which show girls in scantily clad outfits shaking away on the stage of events held by city harvest. i remember watching my own church dancers who I felt looked funny wearing a black leotard under a short dress. Now i know what my church would look to the judging world if a paparazzi were to come in and snap away. Then, there’s one with the Hanna of a guy’s arm that read ‘Jesus, name above all names’, hmm indeed serving no purpose but to depict Jesus freaks as the freaks that they are, and being proud of it. As i said, not related to anything the page is talking about or the page before, worse, it’s choice of graphics are scandalous and without much elaboration as mentioned just now. More appropriate photos or graphics to push their notion would probably be photos of the things in question: their exorbitant equipment, or show some graphs to support their point or smth. To be fair, their images of the new creation building and the congregation of faith community baptist church are relevant.
Reading forums, i am sad looking at how people can be these days. Firstly don’t bull about churches take all their sheep’s money. Yes they take my money, its something called tithes. All churches do that. in fact; everyone with a religion gives money to their place of worship. For centuries. Nothing new. What they use your money for is what’s changing only. If people are to bark, bark about what certain churches prioritize their funds for, not at the tithing procedure.
the point of the article is lost in the report halfway because i am made to feel disgusted by ‘the rise of the mega church’ from start to end. trying to make churches sound like freak shows without really giving some background at least to the way churches usually run all these while. They suggest numerous legitimate points but lost me eventually by the way they fail to really show an expert view of the church environment in Singapore. I am no expert but being a christian, there are things that are not new practices or really no big deal when you look at it objectively, yet is reported theatrically that would make any ignorant person gasp.
Christians NEED to pray that their God’s name won’t be tarnished by this report. People NEED to know that churches are not perfect establishments because they are run by imperfect human beings, that fyi includes the bible’s credibility too so don’t hold it against people for what people wrote. Other things like erm a god, theoretically and theologically, should be nothing less than perfect, anything decide for your own self. For christians this is no reason to abandon religion or lose all hope for churches. Like what the papers said, christians here are very blessed. there are indeed about 700 churches in Singapore. Choose wisely according to your own preference. (aka what the papers say derogatorily: church shop.)
When you are dying, you WILL wonder what will happen, whether you will just dissolve into nothing, or whether is there really is an afterlife. Confirm you had wondered how everything started long long ago, whether it was because of some big bang or who created god if god created us and all those irritating puzzles of life. Why even deep in the jungle, tribes somehow seem to have their own version of a god or two, why we are all destined to look up into the skies and question whether we are our own god or not. Science VS Religion become science proves religion then become religion is science (scientology).
Real or not, one thing is for certain: NOBODY KNOWS. Anything is possible.
Don’t be like my friend who is ignorant and thinks he’s so smart not even trying to find out. Be smart. Like me. Try. Explore and experiement by your own. Don’t listen to people is best cos they don’t know any better. Make a decision cos you know maths? Got one chapter called probability. Choose one god. If wrong… never mind. If you are right, you’re in heaven. :D